Did Elizabeth Warren Lie About Her Native American Heritage to Land a Job at Harvard?
Memes assert that Senator Elizabeth Warren lives in a multi-million-dollar mansion and relied on scant Native American heritage claims to land a job at Harvard.
The Daily Debunker brings you the top stories on m.
Elizabeth Warren lives in a multi-million-dollar mansion and relied on scant Native American heritage claims to land a job at Harvard.
Elizabeth Warrens home is likely worth more than the average American home, and the senator has often spoken of her Native American ancestry.
Elizabeth Warren doesnt live in a mansion valued at several million dollars, evidence is contradictory over whether she used false claims of Native American heritage to gain an edge over other candidates for a job at Harvard or drew a large salary for teaching only one class.
In October 2014, a meme targeting Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-MA) began to circulate on social media sites. In it, Warren is framed as hypocritically exploiting programs aimed at Native Americans to achieve wealth and political power. Examples cited included her purported ownership of a $5.4 million mansion and ahigh-payinggig at Harvard University supposedly achieved solely due to her claim of possessing a small amount of Native American heritage:
The image (which concluded with a reminder of Warrens positions against concentrating power disproportionately amidst the very wealthy) packed a number of claims into one small statement, the first being the value of Warrens Boston-area home.
Public real estate records suggest Warrens house is not by any means what one might imagine a mansion to be, boasting a modest four bedrooms and three to three-and-a-half baths. Warrens home last sold in 1995 for less than $500,000, and market estimates currently vary quite a bit for its potential resale value.
Its fair to say average Americans would find homes in Warrens neighborhood to be out of their price range, and assessments of the value of Warrens home hover between one and two million dollars, far under the $5.4 million cited in the image above. Its possible the estimate came from the range in which Warren listed her home on standard disclosure forms in 2011 [PDF], a pre-set checkbox field that indicates a value anywhere between one and five million dollars.
Although at one point, Warren did draw a large salary for teaching at Harvard (her 2011 campaign disclosureformindicates a salary for 2010-2011 of $429,981 although her paperwork doesnt indicate how many classes she was actually teaching), her 2013 taxfilings[PDF] indicated that she left in January of that year (when she was sworn in to her Senatepost), only retaining an agreement to be able to store some materials at the university and retain an honorary title ofemeritus professor. A Harvard Computer Society (HCS)documentheld Warrens salary was $192,550 at an unspecified juncture, along with $133,453 in other compensation.
The claim about Warrens use of her Native American heritage to obtain a high-paying job at Harvard University appears to date from her 2012 bid against incumbent Scott Brown for his Senate seat. Brown alleged during a debate in 2012:
I think character is important. I think what youre referring to is the fact that Professor Warren claimed that she was a Native American, a person of color, and as you can see, shes not. That being said, she checked the box and she had an opportunity actually to make a decision throughout her career when she applied to Penn and Harvard and she checked the box claiming she was a Native American.And, you know, clearly shes not. That being said, I dont know and neither do the viewers know whether she got ahead as a result of that checking of the box, but the only way that well be able to find that out is to have her release her personnel records, have Harvard release their personnel records to make sure that she did not have an advantage that others were entitled to. When you are a United States Senator you have to pass a test, and one of character and honesty and truthfulness. And I believe, and others believe, that she has failed that test.
The legitimacy of Warrens claims to Native American heritage has certainly been challenged by many critics, and it is true that while Warren was at U. Penn. Law School she put herself on the Minority Law Teacher list as Native American) in the faculty directory of the Association of American Law Schools, and that Harvard Law School at one time promoted Warren as a Native American faculty member. But specific evidence that she gained her position at Harvard (at least in part) through her claims to Native American heritage is lacking. Warren denied applying for special consideration as a person of Native American heritage during her career, and when the matter was examined in 2012 in response to Browns claims, people with whom Warren had worked similarly denied her ancestral backgrounds factoring into the professional opportunities afforded her:
The former chairman of the American Association of Law Schools, David Bernstein, told the Herald that the groups directory once served as a tip sheet for administrators. In the old days before the Internet, youd pull out the AALS directory and look up people, he said. There are schools that, if they were looking for a minority faculty member, would go to that list and might say, I didnt know Elizabeth Warren was a minority.Warren said she didnt know Harvard had used her heritage as proof of diversity until reading about the issue in the news, according to a Herald report. She also denied that she ever tried to gain a professional advantage through her lineage.
Warren responded she was recruited for the positions and did not apply for them; and for the most part, her record did not indicate any identification as part of a minority group:
The Globe obtained a portion of Warrens application to Rutgers, which asks if prospective students want to apply for admission under the schools Program for Minority Group Students. Warren answered no.For her employment documents at the University of Texas, Warren indicated that she was white.
But Penns 2005 Minority Equity Report identified her as the recipient of a 1994 faculty award, listing her name in bold to signify that she was a minority.
The Herald has twice quoted Charles Fried, the head of the Harvard appointing committee that recommended Warren for her position in 1995, saying that the Democratic candidates heritage didnt come up during the course of her hiring. It simply played no role in the appointments process, he said. It was not mentioned and I didnt mention it to the faculty.
The Herald later quoted Fried, a former U.S. Solicitor General under President Ronald Reagan, saying, I can state categorically that the subject of her Native American ancestry never once was mentioned.
In September 2018, theBoston Globepublished the results of aninvestigationover whether Warren was hired at Harvard because had decided to self-identify as a Native American woman and Harvard saw a chance to diversify the law faculty. TheGlobeconcluded that:
In the most exhaustive review undertaken of Elizabeth Warrens professional history, the Globe found clear evidence, in documents and interviews, that her claim to Native American ethnicity was never considered by the Harvard Law faculty, which voted resoundingly to hire her, or by those who hired her to four prior positions at other law schools. At every step of her remarkable rise in the legal profession, the people responsible for hiring her saw her as a white woman.
The Globe examined hundreds of documents, many of them never before available, and reached out to all 52 of the law professors who are still living and were eligible to be in [on the decision]. Some are Warrens allies. Others are not. Thirty-one agreed to talk to the Globe including the law professor who was, at the time, in charge of recruiting minority faculty. Most said they were unaware of her claims to Native American heritage and all but one of the 31 said those claims were not discussed as part of her hire. One professor told the Globe he is unsure whether her heritage came up, but is certain that, if it did, it had no bearing on his vote on Warrens appointment.
In October 2018, Senator Warren released a controversialreporton a DNA analysis that was said to show a pure Native American ancestor appeared in her ancestry in the range of six to 10 generations ago.
In February 2019 theWashington PostsurfacedWarrens 1986 registration card for the State Bar of Texas, on which she identified her race as American Indian.
Hicks, Josh. Did Elizabeth Warren Check the Native American Box When She Applied to Harvard and Penn?
Bierman, Noah. Warren Releases Financial Report.
Bierman, Noah. Document Ties Warren Kin to Cherokees.
Franke-Ruta, Garance. Is Elizabeth Warren Native American or What?
Jacobs, Sally. Elizabeth Warrens Family Has Mixed Memories About Heritage.
Linskey, Annie and Amy Gardner. Elizabeth Warren Apologizes for Calling Herself Native American.
9 May 2019In May 2019, social media users shared evidence of the companys controversial campaign to discourage its workers from unionizing.
10 May 2019The largest bats in the world have wingspans of more than 5 feet.
10 May 2019Finally, something on which the political left and right agree!
9 May 2019A swastika-flag-carrying group was angry over efforts to take an accused Holocaust deniers name off an Arkansas Tech scholarship.
9 May 2019A New York City environmental office once estimated less than 1 percent of households in the city had such disposals.
8 May 2019The spreading of salacious stories about candidates and their families typically coincides with the start of the presidential election cycle.
7 May 2019The bake sale offered different prices for different ethnicities and for females in a parody of affirmative action. The event was criticized as being prejudiced.
2 May 2019Robert Muellers full 448-page legal document might be daunting to read, so here is an 18-page summary he expressly wanted the public to see.
23 April 2019I was a first-time offender, too. A lie is a lie.
16 April 2019Time after time, a major news event produces a big mess to mop up on social media.
This material may not be reproduced without permission.
Snopes and the logo are registered service marks of m